I first started hearing about the Lancome Matte Shakers from one of my favorite YouTubers (Allana Davison). It must have been like a subliminal message because it took several months before I really wanted to try one.
Liquid lipsticks are hit or miss for me (Kat Von D = hit, Anastasia = miss) so I initially passed these babies over for more standard lipstick formulas. But when Bloomingdale’s had a 10% off discount, I decided to give them a try.
I first purchased the shades “Kiss Me Cherie” and “Beige Vintage.” Unfortunately, Bloomingdale’s ran out of the “Beige Vintage” shade before they could ship it and that particular order was canceled. That shade is still on my wishlist so stay tuned for an update!
Formula + Application
The formula is so unique. It’s not drying or sticky like a standard liquid lipstick but instead, feels very sheer and lightweight. It looks shiny when you first apply it and like most liquid lipsticks, it dries to a matte finish. It lasts fairly well without touchups and fades evenly so if you forget to reapply you’ll be left with just a sheer wash of color. True to the name, these liquid lippies need to be shaken before application to get any real color payoff.
I was nervous that the bulky sponge applicator would make it impossible to apply neatly (an issue I’ve had with most liquid lipsticks). But because the formula is so sheer, this type of applicator helps spread the color on easily. The pointed tip helps with precision but it should be noted, that if you want a super bold, clean, precise lip – this product may not be for you. It gives a more sheer, blurred effect, ideal for natural makeup looks.
Once I realized I loved the formula and applicator, I decided to purchase three more shades with an Ulta 20% off coupon last month. I’m such a smart shopper – I know.
The shades I purchased, in addition to “Kiss Me Cherie,” were: “Abrickadabra,” “Berry n’ Clyde,” and “Red’y in 5.” I found the formula to be consistent across all 4 shades. Check out my shade review and try-on below.
Kiss Me Cherie
“Kiss Me Cherie” is described as a “deep brick red” but on me, it’s really more of a bright pinky red. I’m not too mad about it…it’s red enough for the festive holiday season and pink enough to take me through Spring.
Described as “pumpkin spice,” this shade feels true to its description. I love this shade! Warm, neutral, and a little spicy – it’s just right for the season. Not to mention, I love the name. I’m not sure if it has any “brick” tones but the “pumpkin spice” description is on the money. I’m not sure why but it’s coming off slightly shiny in this picture but rest assured, this shade dries matte just like the others.
Berry n’ Clyde
This was the only one that I was slightly disappointed with. Given that it has “berry” in the name, I was expecting it to be…ya know…berry colored. It could just be my skintone, but as you can see, this is nowhere near a berry tone. It’s more like a hot pink and to be honest, I’m seriously considering exchanging it for a true berry shade. Maybe I’ll have better luck with “The Grape Escape” or “Plum Girl.”
Red’y in 5
This shade is described as a “warm fiery red” and it’s just that. I wasn’t sure if it was going to be flattering on my pink undertones but after swiping it on, it might just be my favorite of the bunch! I think I’ll get way more wear out of it come spring/summer.
Regarding price, these liquid lipsticks clock in at $22 a pop. Definitely more expensive than your standard drugstore lippie but the formula and application of these are so unique that you really can’t dupe it. Not yet, anyway. It will be interesting to see if L’Oreal (Lancome’s parent company) releases something similar for the drugstore.
I collect lipsticks from drugstore to luxury brands and I’ve never tried anything like these. I’m not sure how long a bottle will last if you use it every day, but I’d say they’re worth the price tag.
Like I said, the formula of these lipsticks is truly unique. However, I do think the shade names and descriptions are off. So do as I say and not as I do – visit a Lancome counter in person if you can to try the shades on.
What do you all think? Will you be giving these matte lip shakers a go? Comment below with your favorite shade. 🙂